How To Do a Literature Review: Webinar Q&A

Guest post by Raymond Pun

This post originally appeared on Sage Campus blog here.

Looking for some guidance on your literature review? Raymond Pun answers all your burning questions submitted during the Q&A of our latest webinar on ‘How to do a literature review’.


The foundation of a high-quality research paper is a strong literature review. Yet knowing exactly where to begin and ground your research can often feel overwhelming. In our latest webinar , Raymond Pun explored the key stages of planning, conducting, and writing a literature review. During the Q&A session there were many great questions that came through that couldn’t be answered. Here are a few of them with some further insights from Raymond himself. 

Question 1: How do you define the scope of a literature review, and how far back should it go?

Two questions are asked here; the answer depends on your research study and goals. Generally, to define the scope of a literature review, you want to set the parameters for your research - what you will cover and what you will leave out. Your research question(s) can narrow down the types of studies you will be looking at; you might also be limited by your circumstances (i.e., deadline, instructor’s recommendation). If you need to start with ten studies or ten studies within the last ten years, then that is what you may consider first. So there are many factors and questions to consider. How far back you want to go depends entirely on your question(s) and the disciplines involved. Fields like the humanities or topics with a historical study may require the inclusion of critical and foundational works (see question 6). 

Recent literature may be up to five years old and may or may not be relevant to your study. Your instructor may have guidelines for this, but overall, the goal is to give your reader a sense of the literature discussed by researchers and to demonstrate your awareness of important studies and researchers relevant to your own study.

Question 2: How can we move beyond summarizing studies to identify research gaps and demonstrate novelty?

Good question! This is where synthesis work happens. Your sources need to be in conversation with one another. To synthesize, you take the main parts of each study and examine how they overlap in ideas, concepts, or approaches to create something new that you see. When you synthesize multiple studies, you may identify the gaps in each study and recognize common themes or issues. That is where your research can address the gap. 

Synthesizing in writing requires you to demonstrate to your reader that you are making sense of the studies in relation to your own work and uncovering something new from there. Synthesizing studies is not a simple task, but you get to practice it and see what works. In essence, you want to avoid summarizing studies because summarizing does not help you recognize the gaps or introduce something new.

Question 3: How can researchers use generative AI responsibly in literature reviews?

There are several ways to use generative AI tools responsibly to support literature review. Using the tool to double-check citations and seeing the source directly is essential. AI tools will hallucinate, so you should not take their responses as accurate; always double-check in a library catalog (e.g., worldcat.org). Some have used AI tools to brainstorm keywords for a database or to analyze their drafts to identify areas for improvement. These may be appropriate, depending on what your instructor/program allows. Overall, do not offload your writing, thinking, and reading skills to these tools because the purpose of your educational process is to struggle, develop, and sharpen these skills.

Question 4: How do you navigate a literature review when there have not been many studies on your topic? Do I look in parallel fields? 

First, I highly recommend avoiding writing sentences like “Few studies have focused on this topic…” in your literature review. I am guilty of having written such a sentence in the past! 

Generally speaking, finding one or two studies might help expand the sources for your research. You would check the references of such studies, look up those sources, and read to see how they may or may not align with your own study. I mentioned the cookie crumb trail, where you may not need to do any database searching, and explore what others have found and analyzed. Also, be sure to look at sources that utilize a specific theory or method that might be similar to your own, where you may analyze its strengths and limitations. You could look into parallel fields, but again, if you are a student, your instructor may prefer a specific, insular approach (i.e, stick within your field). 

Question 5: How would you handle reviewing sources that are not a language you understand and incorporate into your lit review?

It is a good question to ask yourself: Should I include this source if I cannot read the article in its original language? I would say do not include it because you may misread or misunderstand the article’s purpose or interpretations. Some may say you can use translation tools or seek a translator after finding out that it may be useful or relevant. However, you also need to ask yourself whether your instructor (for a class) will allow this, because they may not be able to read the article and may question your use of it; check with your instructor to see whether they allow using sources in other languages. 

Question 6: What do you think about using sources that are good for the literature review, but are not current (like in the 1900s), despite still being relevant?  

We had a similar question raised during the Q&A on this. It depends on the discipline and research topic; drawing on articles from the 1900s can highlight foundational studies that introduce important theories or methods and have influenced subsequent research and your own. That is where you could mention older studies that are pertinent to your own. If you are also conducting a study and need to understand how the topic has changed over time, it may make sense to include articles from different periods and explain the evolution of the research (e.g., new methods, insights, theories, etc). 

In case you missed it, the recording for the webinar ‘How to do a literature review’ is now live. Catch up below:

Previous
Previous

Webinar follow-up: “How to Conduct Inclusive Research: Practical Choices for Responsible Methodology”

Next
Next

Upcoming How to Do Research and Get Published webinars