Theorizing Through Literature Reviews: The Miner-Prospector Continuum
by Janet Salmons, Ph.D., Research Community Manager for SAGE Methodspace
A feature topic in the Organizational Research Methods journal, Rigorous and Impactful Literature Reviews, explores methodologies for conducting review research. Some of the articles are open access, the others are available until April 12, 2023. Methodspace is highlighting this useful collection with a series of interviews and related resources.
Are you a miner or a prospector?
In the article “Theorizing Through Literature Reviews: The Miner-Prospector Continuum” Dermot Breslin and Caroline Gatrell pose an intriguing question: do you approach the literature review as a miner or as a prospector? Or is your position as a review researcher somewhere in between?
Watch this interview for their further explanation of these roles and the implications for your study and its contribution.
Want to learn more and see examples? Read these articles by Dermot and Caroline:
Breslin, D., Gatrell, C., & Bailey, K. (2020). Developing insights through reviews: reflecting on the 20th anniversary of the international journal of management reviews. International Journal of Management Reviews, 22(1), 3-9.
Breslin, D., Callahan, J., & Iszatt‐White, M. (2021). Future‐proofing IJMR as a leading management journal: Reach, relevance and reputation. International Journal of Management Reviews, 23(4), 431-442.
Fan, D., Breslin, D., Callahan, J. L., & Iszatt‐White, M. (2022). Advancing literature review methodology through rigour, generativity, scope and transparency. International Journal of Management Reviews, 24(2), 171-180.
Post, C., Sarala, R., Gatrell, C., & Prescott, J. E. (2020). Advancing theory with review articles. Journal of Management Studies, 57(2), 351-376.
Gatrell, C., Ladge, J. J., & Powell, G. N. (2022). A review of fatherhood and employment: Introducing new perspectives for management research. Journal of Management Studies, 59(5), 1198-1226.
Bios
Caroline Gatrell is Professor of Organization Studies, University of Liverpool Management School, where she is Associate Dean, Research.
She offers a distinguished research record and was awarded the British Academy of Management Research Medal in 2020. Her research critically analyses, from a socio-cultural perspective, how professional workers (often parents) balance paid work and family lives. Current research projects include a focus on fathers and employment; studies on the ‘maternal body’ within organizational settings and research on how senior women clergy experience careers, work and family
Caroline is a Fellow of the Academy of Social Sciences and a Fellow of the British Academy of Management. Caroline is presently Chair of the Research Committee, Chartered Association of Business Schools and is a General Editor, Journal of Management Studies
Dermot Breslin is a full professor of Organisational Behaviour at Rennes School of Business, France, director of the research centre, Rethinking Tomorrow's Organization, and fellow of the British Academy of Management. His research focuses on evolutionary approaches in organization studies, organizational learning and change, and has been published in leading journals including the Organization Studies, International Journal of Management Reviews, Organizational Research Methods, and Work Employment and Society. Dermot sits on the editorial boards of the Journal of Management Studies, International Small Business Journal and the International Journal of Entrepreneurial Behaviour & Research, and previously served as Co Editor-in-Chief for the International Journal of Management Reviews between 2017-2022. Before entering academia he worked as a chartered engineer in the steel, aluminium and paper industries
Methodspace posts about Literature Reviews and Review Research
Watch this recent webinar on Research Impact. Dr Tamika Heiden and Dr Josh Gladden discuss how they have encountered and promoted research impact within their fields, focusing on strategies for bridging academic and societal impact.
Gorilla has announced the opening of applications for their 2024 Multiplayer Grant, reflecting on the success of the Spring Grant. Winning projects showcased Gorilla’s tools, driving forward psychological and behavioral research.
In the fourth post of our Using Codebooks in Qualitative Research series, authors, Angie Sibley-White & Gisela Oliveira (Senior Lecturers in Education at De Montfort University), explore how codebooks benefit solo researchers. Beyond team projects, codebooks enhance research rigor, facilitate reflexivity, and support early theorization, making them invaluable tools for independent qualitative researchers.
In the third post of our Using Codebooks in Qualitative Research series, Angie Sibley-White (Senior Lecturer in Education at De Montfort University), reflects on her experience using a codebook during her PhD research. She shares insights on how a codebook can help novice researchers navigate complex data analysis, ensuring rigor, transparency, and consistency.
Introducing the Teaching category winner for the 2024 Concept Grants from Sage: The Media Education Research Lab (MERL) at UC Berkeley develops tools and methods to teach students how to critically assess diversity in film and television, promoting media literacy and nuanced analysis.
Introducing the Doing Research category winner for the 2024 Concept Grants from Sage: Y: The Home of LLMs is a versatile digital twin platform that simulates social media dynamics using LLMs, allowing researchers to explore and test social scenarios with realistic, customizable synthetic data.
Introducing the Learning category winner for the 2024 Concept Grants from Sage: educate_R suite simplifies advanced data analysis for social science students and researchers, offering intuitive tools like Data Distillery for data cleaning and visualization.
In the second post of our Using Codebooks in Qualitative Research series, our authors, Angie Sibley-White & Gisela Oliveira (Senior Lecturers in Education at De Montfort University), dive into the process of creating a codebook. We guide you through the essential steps, from defining your goals to developing and refining codes, ensuring consistency and clarity in your qualitative analysis.
Welcome to Using Codebooks in Qualitative Research. In the first post, our authors, Angie Sibley-White & Gisela Oliveira (Senior Lecturers in Education at De Montfort University) define codebooks, explore their flexibility, and discuss how they enhance data organization, consistency, and rigor in research.
Annotiva, a 2023 Sage Concept Grant recipient, gives an update on the development of their AI-assisted tool to enhance qualitative coding by predicting ambiguities and improving collaboration among novice researchers.
Catch up with Gorilla’s Shop Builder 2. Developed after receiving the 2023 Sage Concept Grant, it features a modular design, mobile compatibility, skinnability, and improved customization, enhancing researchers' flexibility and user experience.
BigKnowledge's BoKMap platform transforms mapping principles into a "GPS for knowledge," visualizing unstructured text data in a map-like form, aiding in document exploration and discovery across various domains. Read more for an update on ths 2023 Concept Grant winning project.
We check in with GailBot, the £15k Concept Grant winner. Combining ASR and ML to capture paralinguistic features, GailBot has been revamped for wider researcher use. After a week-long UCLA hack session, we’re addressing internationalization and user-driven feature requests, ensuring scalable and versatile transcription. Join our Slack Community for updates!
This blog by Nur Şat, Associate Professor at Hitit University, Türkiye discusses a project which bridged a critical gap in Public Administration (PA) research by offering a free, online training program on qualitative methods. Master's students and academics honed their skills in areas like proposal development and data analysis. The program attracted strong interest, with a mobile-friendly website garnering nearly 2,000 visits. Participants reported high satisfaction and a significant improvement in their research abilities. This experience offers valuable insights for academics seeking to organize similar projects.
Listen to this interview, and check out Rhys Jones’ latest book: Statistical Literacy: A Beginner's Guide.
Find examples and guidance about collecting data on blogs or vlogs.
Explore the significance of Juneteenth in US history and reflect on inclusive research practices with us! We highlight the role that researchers can play in designing research that is ethical, community based and transformative.
This blog post is the eighth, and final, post in a follow-on to our 2021 “The future of computational social science is Black” series, about a Summer Institute in Computational Social Science organized by Howard University and Mathematica. It continues to bring the power of computational social science to the issues of systemic racism and inequality in America. This marks the third iteration of the successful SICSS model being hosted by a Historically Black College or University.
While some types of online research use communication tools to interact with remote participants, digital methods use online approaches to study online phenomena.
This blog is the seventh, and penultimate post, in a follow-on to our 2021 “The future of computational social science is Black” series, about a Summer Institute in Computational Social Science organized by Howard University and Mathematica. It continues to bring the power of computational social science to the issues of systemic racism and inequality in America. This marks the third iteration of the successful SICSS model being hosted by a Historically Black College or University.
Dr. Stommel brings clarity to the messy world of data collection on social media.
This blog post is the sixth of eight in a follow-on to our 2021 “The future of computational social science is Black” series, about a Summer Institute in Computational Social Science organized by Howard University and Mathematica. It continues to bring the power of computational social science to the issues of systemic racism and inequality in America. This marks the third iteration of the successful SICSS model being hosted by a Historically Black College or University.
Latanya Sweeney, scholar of technology science, Daniel Paul Professor of the Practice of Government and Technology at the Harvard Kennedy School and in the Harvard Faculty of Arts and Sciences, and director and founder of the Public Interest Tech Lab, delivered the keynote address for SICSS-Howard/Mathematica 2023.
Do you have concerns about how to carry out data collection with vulnerable populations online? Find research strategies for reaching vulnerable people online.
This collection of open access articles offers multidisciplinary examples, guidance, and perspectives about online experimental research.
What are some of the issues researchers face, and what are the experiences of online participants? This collection of open-access articles includes diverse examples and perspectives.
This blog post is the fifth of eight in a follow-on to our 2021 “The future of computational social science is Black” series, about a Summer Institute in Computational Social Science organized by Howard University and Mathematica. It continues to bring the power of computational social science to the issues of systemic racism and inequality in America. This marks the third iteration of the successful SICSS model being hosted by a Historically Black College or University.
How do you know online participants are who they say they are? This collection of articles explores the issues - and solutions.
Informed consent is the term given to the agreement between researcher and participant. In this post Janet Salmons offers suggestions about the intersections of the Internet communications, ethics and participants.